85th Academy Awards 2013
Nominated for 1 award.
Nominated for Best Documentary Short Subject (Jon Alpert, Matthew O’Neill).
Watched June 30, 2014.
Redemption is a unique view of life in New York. On the very doorstep of nice homes and large buildings, condominiums and the Empire State Building itself, the impoverished of the city spend endless hours, day in and day out, collecting bottles and cans from trashcans in order to redeem them for five cents a piece.
This documentary short follows a basic premise to tell a sad story. It follows different people, from veterans and the elderly, to immigrants and single mothers. Some of them live on the streets and band together from a mutual need of safety. Others live in a one room apartment with at least six other people. Some New Yorkers help the collectors, while others turn a blind eye.
The one bedroom apartment is like a scene from hoarders. It makes the situation more real and brings the message of the film home. It doesn’t matter where you come from. There is a woman who worked for Microsoft for years, but now her Social Security benefits don’t cover everything and she has to can all day, fighting with an angry and overly competitive Chinese woman who will steal your cans right from under you. Each person has a story.
The film is very transparent. It doesn’t seek to hide its message or motives under artistic camera work or in-studio interview footage. It is all on the streets. There is little to no symbolism. It is simple. This probably makes it more powerful, and yet from an artistic standpoint it is very blah and unimpressive. It transitions from character to character well, and it tells their stories even better, but there is nothing else to it. Perhaps its length limited it, but its rawness was a negative for me.
The documentary is less than half an hour long. If the story sounds interesting to you, then I would definitely recommend it. I am a lover of documentaries and don’t consider my time wasted by viewing it. It did open my eyes a bit more to the poverty around us, which is probably the biggest goal of the film, and therefore it did its job. However, in my opinion, a film should exceed the bounds of just “doing its job” in order to deserve an Oscar nomination.