The Noose (1928) | Jamie Daily

The Noose (1928)
1st Academy Awards 1929
Nominated for Best Actor (Richard Barthelmess).
Vaulted Film


Apparently The Noose is kept in the archives at the Library of Congress–essentially it is still in the Warner Bros. Vault and has yet to be released.  If anyone knows where or if I could find it, I would greatly appreciate it.  As it is, I assume that one day I will be able to watch this film but am very disappointed that I don’t get to watch Richard Barthelmess in action again quite yet.


In the first ever Oscar nominations, everything was different.  The winners were announced ahead of time, only silent films were nominated, the attendees purchased tickets, and the talent could be nominated for their body of work within the set date restrictions, not just for a single piece.  Barthelmess’ performance in The Noose was supposedly to complement his success in The Patent Leather Kid.


From a bit of research, it looks like it will be difficult to locate quite a few of the films from this year.  Even though this is upsetting and certainly upsets my goal of watching every nominated film… ever… there’s nothing I can really do about it.  So I will move on and stop complaining about it.


I found this review online (Alice Joyce on and instead of summarizing a movie that I have not seen, I thought it would be interesting to share a review from 1928.


“From Variety, March 21, 1928




“First National production and release. Richard Barthelmess starred, Alice JoyceLina BasquetteThelma Todd, Montague Love and Robert T. Haines featured Scenario adapted from the stage play by Willard Mack and H.H. Van Loan. At Strand, New York, week March 17. Running time, around 75 minutes.

Nickie Elkins Richard Barthelmess
Buck Gordon Montague Love
Jim Conley Robert E. O’Connor
Tommy Jay Eaton
Dot Lina Basquette
Phyllis Thelma Todd
Seth McNillan Ed Brady
Dave Fred Warren
Bill Chase William Davidson
Mrs. Bancroft Alice Joyce
The Warden William Walling
The Governor Robert T. Haines
Craig Ernest Hilliard
Priest Emile Chautard
Judge Romaine Fielding
Cabaret Girls Yola d’Avril, Corliss Palmer,

Kay English, Cecil Brunner,

Janice Peters, Ruth Lord,

May Atwood

“”The Noose,” with Richard Barthelmess, gives First National a drawing program feature that will stand well up to follow Barthelmess’ great hit in “The Patent Leather Kid.” It’s an extremely well directed and played drama, with meller tendencies, a touch of the underworld with a real cabaret scene one of the standouts, but underneath the rest a virile story of suspensive qualities that are all taken advantage of. It’s in.

“This picture is said to have been taken under the natural light, or at least the cabaret scene was. Natural light is indicated throughout. If the first of that kind, its defects can be remedied if natural light is thought beneficial. While the trade may detect a different lighting scheme, it’s doubtful if the lays will. At times the photography is misty and not always uniform in light, a greyish tint often appearing. That followed into the cabaret scenes for the side rooms, employed there, but on the floor the lighting was evenly bright. At the Burbank studios when this scene was taken it was said that the heat form the big arcs was terrific on the people beneath them.

“Toward the finish of “The Noose” extraordinary suspense is maintained and it’s two-sided. First is whether Nickie Elkins will be hanged and he is walking toward the gallows for some time, while the other is whether the Governor’s wife will confess to her husband that Nickie is her son. Neither happens. What did happen was that Mrs. Governor phones the warden over her husband’s private wire ordering the execution stopped, and the Governor, when advised, calling the boy before him, to intimate that a pardon would be forthcoming.

“Nickie had shot and killed his father, Buck Gordon, within five minutes after Buck had told the lad who his parents were. His mother was the Governor’s wife, said Buck, and if he were sent away for killing another gangster, Nickie would have to appeal to his mother to save him. Upon Nickie’s refusal, Buck said he would shake down the Governor’s wife himself then for the freedom and the coin. Nickie said he wouldn’t and, to prove it, shot his father, who had brought him up from babyhood without Nickie aware of his father or mother.

“Other than the cabaret scene, no action of moment. A bit of shooting, but the play’s action very slight.

“Barthelmess’ Nickie a natural for him, although Barthelmess is more likable in action. That’s where he shines. Nevertheless, Barthelmess has a distinctive individuality on the screen, and it’s very valuable for few own it. He always suggests impulsiveness, and that’s suspense in itself, continually.

“Lina Basquette does Dot, the cabaret girl, nicely. In the prison and Governor’s room scenes, Miss Basquette was admirable. She’s in love with Nickie, who was about to be regenerated by a “nice lady from uptown” just as he bumped off his suddenly discovered dad. Thelma Todd as the nice lady only had to see that her very blonde hair was marcelled.

“Alice Joyce had a difficult emotional role as the governor’s wife. She looked the part, excepting when opposite Barthelmess, when she appeared too young, but Miss Joyce will probably not be miffed over that. She had to express extreme heart anguish and yet refrain from confessing to her husband even for a commutation or pardon that the condemned boy was her own son. That made it quite a serious moment of acting for her and also an unreal character, but she got by well enough under the conditions.

“Jay Eaton as Tommy, the stager of the floor show, minced it up a little for a laugh; the girls behind him displayed good coaching and legs. William Walling as the warden had but one chance, but made that bit look very good. Montague Love did the heavy Buck. That was soft for him, doing his best in looking the role. Robert T. Haines was another who perfectly looked the Governor, giving the part all the dignity it called for.

“Barthelmess’ backward leap into the front rank of the male b.o. cards will be helped along by this one.”


My favourite bit was when the author said that the show girls had “good coaching and legs.”  What was yours?

Sources: B+ Movie BlogAlice Joyce on

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s